"Had salty bagels shipped to Mechanicsville, MD for my Mom for Mother's Day, they arrived in 2 days and she loved them, especially toasted! My Mom was born and raised in Brooklyn, NY!"
"On our sampling, the bagels arrived in excellent condition - when toasted, they were excellent. Coming from real New Yorker's that is saying a lot!!"
"...the bagels there are so good they can cause people to do crazy things."
Buying Mail Order Bagels - Common Questions
There are numerous websites that sell bagels online. Why should I purchase from St. Pete Bagel Co.?
Glad you asked! Here are some of the benefits of purchasing bagels online from our estore:
- All of our bagels are authentic New York-style and genuine Kosher; you can enjoy delicious, traditional bagels anywhere in the United States!
- We vacuum seal all packages and ship the same day that the bagels are baked; we guarantee that your order will arrive fresh!
- Guaranteed prompt response to all email and phone inquiries; you will never feel out of the loop!
- Our company has been around since 1987. In 2011, St. Pete Bagel Co. was voted the Best Bagel Shop in Tampa Bay by the readers and editors of the Creative Loafing Magazine. No need to worry about where your bagels are coming from; we are a local, family-owned bakery.
How do you ensure that my bagel order will arrive fresh?
In addition to only utilizing overnight and 2-3 day shipping, we also vacuum-seal all packages. Doing so prevents the formation of mold and ensures that your package will arrive fresh!
Is there a minimum number of bagels that I have to order?
We kindly ask that you purchase a minimum of 6 bagels per order. This arrangement allows us to provide the highest-quality Kosher bagels for the lowest possible cost.
Will I be able to track my order?
Yes. In addition to receiving a confirmation that we have received your order, we will also send you a unique tracking number when your mail order bagels are on the way.
So, how much does it cost?
Each bagel costs $0.75. Shipping and handling varies based on your location and whether you opt for overnight or 2-3 day shipping. We do our best to provide the best product at the lowest possible cost.
What shipping carrier do you use?
Our primary carrier is the U.S. Postal Service; we offer both Priority Mail (2-3 day) and Express Mail (overnight) shipping. Both options include delivery confirmation and tracking. You will receive a tracking number by email once your order is complete.
Do you offer international shipping?
Yes! Customers may choose from USPS Express Mail International (3-5 days) and USPS Global Express Guaranteed (1-3 days) when ordering abroad. Unfortunately, to preserve the quality of the bagels, we cannot offer USPS Priority Mail International at this time.
How can I contact you?
If you have further questions or concerns, please don't hesitate to get in touch. If you'd prefer to speak with someone by phone, you can call (727)522-3377 and ask to speak with the store manager. Please note that we're only available to answer the phone between the hours of 7:00 AM and 1:00 PM EST, Monday - Sunday. Our goal is to respond to all inquiries within 12 hours.

